It sounds like a very busy concept for Atraxa... There is nothing wrong with wanting to build a Super friends deck with a sub-theme, but tokens do not get proliferated. Nor can token engines synergize or assist Atraxa in the way that cards like
Viral Drake or
Thrummingbird can. I guess the big
Mystery here and what will make or break your idea is your choice of planeswalkers. You would have to select a cast that specifically helps synergize these two different concepts. If you do this, I would strongly suggest running
Ajani Steadfast (...his -2) and any other walkers you can find with similar mecanisms.
In Esper I compiled a list of creatures that interlock and can go Infinite in both the
Nim Deathmantle and
Ashnod’s Altar AND
Karmic Guide +
Reveillark + any sac outlet combos...
Reef WormAngel of InventionExperimental AviatorMarsh FlitterMausoleum GuardVisionary AugmenterWeaponcraft EnthusiastWhirler RoguePriest of GixKnight Captain of EosI also like to run a third engine along with those other two.
Adarkar Valkyrie +
Thornbite Staff, because if one of the other two engines go infinite through
Ashnod’s Altar then the
thornbite staff is a ping to kill win-con. If not it can combo with
Adarkar Valkyrie to go a lil wider with higher quality 187 infinite loops like
Yosei, the morning star,
Kokusho, the evening Star, and
Keiga, the tide star.
Not sure if this helps... I still feel like it’s counter-intuitive for Atraxa, but it’s always worth play testing. 🤔🙂
If you want more infinity ideas check out my
Ertai, the Corrupted deck. It’s a combo deck packed with possible infinite loops.