Nachrichten

1

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 29, 2020, 02:59:08 Nachmittag »

TY - so now i just have to cut one more card.

I am still thinking about the azra oddsmaker and cathartic reunion. maybe i should ditch both for lightning greaves just for the protection of Anje or elixer of immortality against graveyard hate.

2

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 28, 2020, 05:40:33 Nachmittag »

So now i am down to 103 cards. I have set an eye on 2 specific cards:
Azra Odsmaker - while I like the card - I mostly wont be able to regulary connect with opponents for combat damage to use the effect.
Cathartic Renunion - while the draw 3 is good - discarding 2 can be hard sometimes.

But we need to cut one more card.
maybe rite of flame or simian spirit guide - skirk prospector, blood pet can all be used as a creature to discard an returned to hand with phyrexian reclamation and jeweled amulet can be used later too

Suggestions?

3

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 28, 2020, 03:13:02 Nachmittag »

Your right so I will swap the lands but keep the march. TY

4

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 28, 2020, 02:11:23 Nachmittag »

Hi!

Thanks for the feedback:

I will put out Street Wraith, Ichor Slick and Tectonic Reformation
I am a bit more hesitant with the others:
Asylum Visitor is still a madness card and works with Anje.
Cut // Ribbons is an outlet for the worldgorger combo.
Restless Dreams is here to get back creature cards with madness and discard non madness cards to futher rummage with Anje.
I will not play scavanger Grounds due to the fact that i need my graveyard, but maybe i should play more gravehate.
i play the depletion lands to get a turn two Anje even though they come in tapped.
and the marsh is a redundancy for the worldgorger combo i run.

5

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 28, 2020, 01:07:09 Nachmittag »

Hi thanks for the feedback. I did as you told me and now I can see that i may pack a little much removal but on the one hand I don´t want to cut the madness cards due to Anjes effect and around 20-24 are necessary to be able to rummage with her but the non madness removal is the only one I run for artifacts, planeswalkers and enchantments. So the next place to cut would be my filter section. Any suggestions here?

6

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 27, 2020, 02:07:30 Nachmittag »

Hi and thank you. Yes I read the information. I tryed to fit it into the recomendations but still kept my own way. I try to adjust it a bit more. Phyrexian Reclamation seem like a good addition but does not help with cutting cards  Maybe in exchange for Garna even though Garna has higher highs but Phyrexian Reclamation is more consistent. I like magewrite stone but would focus more on getting madness cards back from grave to rummage again ;
The mana ramp part is difficult - on the one hand I want to be fast due to my playgroup playing lots of value commanders like meeren, teysa, etc. and I kind of have to outperform them in terms of speed. I will not win against them in the lategame except with my combo - so yes I kinda need the speed and will upgrade to cards like chrome mox etc. later on.

7

Commander Deck Reviews / Need help with cutting cards from Anje - mix of power l., price and durdly

« am: Dezember 27, 2020, 12:14:55 Nachmittag »

https://deckstats.net/decks/126345/1392900-anje

Hi there, thanks for clicking on the link first. I find myself in the position of cutting 15 more cards from my Anje list and don´t know where to go? Maybe with the rummage effects like faithless etc - due to the fact that Anje proides that too. Or with the reanimation spells - only the enchantments work with the worldgorger combo. Or even the reanimation targets themselfs - like Garna and pyschosis crawler or syr conrad which are maybe way to overcosted but i like the effects they provide and they are a bit more on the durdly side. I find it easier to build highly optimized then with a bit more durdl but i don´t want my deck to be super hated out at every table.
For the mana base. I tryed to get every cheap way of getting a turn 2 Anje.
As far as budget goes I own the expensive cards that are still in like dockside, reanimate, gamble, necromancy, dance of the dead, deflecting swat, entomb and lands. So the only real expensive thing would be the dragon itself.
I really appreciate your feedback and hope that we can trim this list together to produce a nice deck.

Have a nice day.

8

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 29, 2020, 05:12:40 Nachmittag »

Hi again. Thanks so far for the help:

I have 2 more questions:

Would you consider cutting enduring renewal?

And is Tithe Taker worth the effect?

9

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 28, 2020, 01:03:17 Nachmittag »

Hi! Thanks for the advise.

I play the Butcher because I have one and I don´t want to invest in a Grave Pact jet, but it will replace it some time in the future. In terms of ramp I think I will cut wayfarers, but on that note: Would it be more benefitial to put in a knight of the white orchard? I have a love/hate relaionship with chainer: On one Hand he has one of the best recurrsion abilities in the game and I can surpass the creature exile with sacrificing them in response. But if I don´t have a sac out its wasted...

10

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 27, 2020, 10:47:49 Vormittag »

PS.: Most of the expensive cards are already in my collection except for Phyrexian Altar and Tower, Lilliana and Massacre Wurm, but he got reprinted so   Would you recommend Sheoldred since she is going to be reprinted too?

11

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 27, 2020, 10:45:44 Vormittag »

Thanks again for the help. I am still cutting down and I am at 108/107 cards right now. To clarify the issue with nezumi. I thought that the card just fits well with the ability to clear graveyards and beeing and creature to get back with my recurrsion spells. And if it flips it does just that My alternative would have been Tymareth, while he has the upside in terms of value, he doesn´t have the second effect and is bb in his mana costs

12

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 25, 2020, 01:28:06 Nachmittag »

At first thanks for the great help from you guys. I just did a real quick look over and cut 8 cards and deleted some of the not wanted in the sideboard section. I will go over the deck for a second time now and estimate again what i want to keep. Thanks for the recommandation with fell shep I find it especially hard to decide which token generators i should keep and which not. E.g.: Is Seraph of the Scales worth it? (I know u have 2 - 4 spirits from him dying but I could have the same effect with Ministrant of Obligation for 3 cmc instead of 4) but on the other hand the Keywords are good. But is it worth it next to a doomed disenter or hunted witness? I dont know... Same goes for Ancient Stone Idol (this would be switched out for a wurmcoil engine if I will afford one..).
Thanks for the recommendation to cut the drain cards, I thought i need them to be consistant with the drain
In terms of gravehate: I liked the idea to be able to recurr nezumi and if it is able to flip it doubbles as a reanimationspell. Thought also about Tymareth and or the Leyline but just liked the idea
Also thought about cutting Kalitas and/or Overseer but I like the idea of both, for now I cut Kalitas since I have an Overseer with me Also should I still include cards like Swords to P. and Anguished Unmaking etc?

13

Commander Deck Reviews / First commander deck i really build by myself - Need help with cutting...

« am: Juni 24, 2020, 04:36:37 Nachmittag »

https://deckstats.net/decks/126345/1658929-teysa-karlov

I need help to cut the "last" 22 cards from my list. Would appreciate your time and effort greatly Don´t look at Tokens, Sideboard and Maybeboard. These are the cuts i already made...

14

[de] Deck-Bewertungen / [EDH / Commander] Arcades, the Strategist

« am: Februar 22, 2019, 11:43:12 Vormittag »

Arcades, the Strategist
Hi erstmal!
Baue schon seit einiger Zeit an einem Defender Commander, aber bin mir noch nicht so ganz sicher welche der letzen Karten raussollen. Was meint ihr so? Ich bin offen für Anregungen und Hilfe, es handelt sich hierbei um mein erstes selbstgebautes Comander nachdem ich im Herbst nach 6/7 Jahren Pause wieder eingestiegen bin.
Ich bin am überlegen rhystic study, smothering Tithe, marble titan, ghostly prison und propaganda rauszunehmen und vielleicht noch paradox engine und intruder alarm (weil ich die beiden nur für eine Wincon mit mehreren Karten brauche) und falls dem so wäre würde auch der Labratory Maniac rausfallen.
Command Beacon und Teferi´s Protection sind derzeit einfach außerhalb meines Budgets.
Ich hoffe euch gefällt was ihr seht und bin für Anregungen jederzeit offen.
Gruß Ari