1
Deck Comments / Re: (List) The Best Creature Removal for EDH - Comments
« em: Abril 23, 2020, 03:03:22 pm »
First up, thanks for the great list.
While I disagree with your comments on Maelstrom Pulse (it's invaluable on account of its flexibility, particularly great use against token generators), I'm curious why you took Abzan Charm off the list, I find it and Sultai Charm to be very high value removal in the decks that can run them. Versatility is key at instant speed. If you're keeping mana open for removal but don't find a target worthy of [insert instant speed removal spell here] and haven't played anything for the X mana you kept up, then having an alternative on the same card is extremely useful. Particularly as you can use the charms for card draw.
While I disagree with your comments on Maelstrom Pulse (it's invaluable on account of its flexibility, particularly great use against token generators), I'm curious why you took Abzan Charm off the list, I find it and Sultai Charm to be very high value removal in the decks that can run them. Versatility is key at instant speed. If you're keeping mana open for removal but don't find a target worthy of [insert instant speed removal spell here] and haven't played anything for the X mana you kept up, then having an alternative on the same card is extremely useful. Particularly as you can use the charms for card draw.