[EDH / Commander] cEDH Tier List

[iamfat322]

You put Yidris, Maelstrom Wielder higher than I would think with my very limited understanding of the format. Is there a combo that I'm missing?

[robort]

Let me guess, you don't think I do.

Quite the opposite

[Soren841]

Let me guess, you don't think I do.

Quite the opposite

Jus making sure. Can't hear tone on the interwebs

[Soren841]

You put Yidris, Maelstrom Wielder higher than I would think with my very limited understanding of the format. Is there a combo that I'm missing?

He's a storm commander

[robort]

Let me guess, you don't think I do.

Quite the opposite

\

Jus making sure. Can't hear tone on the interwebs

That was what the smiley face was for

[Soren841]

I've done my fair share of sarcastic smileys lmao

[Soren841]

Revision 11

Added/removed cards:
+1 Ayula, Queen Among Bears Mid Power
+1 Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis Mid Power (Need a list to change my mind)
+1 Krenko, Tin Street Kingpin Mid Power
+1 Morophon, the Boundless Mid Power
+1 Pashalik Mons Mid Power
+1 Sisay, Weatherlight Captain Mid Power
+1 The First Sliver Max Power
+1 Urza, Lord High Artificer Competitive
+1 Yawgmoth, Thran Physician Mid Power


As always, any of these are open to debate (please liven up this thread a bit), but remember you need to have a decklist, preferably with stats, not just arguments.

[Morganator 2.0]

Did you see that the TappedOut list made Thrasios+Tymna tier 0? What are your thoughts on that?

[Soren841]

I think it's one of the stupidest things I've ever seen.. yes they're the best sans red option, that's not a question. But TFS is the best 5c Food Chain option.. being the best at what they do isn't enough. There ARE decks stronger than T&T.

[Red_Wyrm]

Did you see that the TappedOut list made Thrasios+Tymna tier 0? What are your thoughts on that?

What is tier 0. I thought tier 1 was maximum power. Are there any other dudes in tier 0?

[WWolfe]

Tappedout (which is a very biased list) has added a Tier (Tier 0- Overpowered). The only commanders on it are T&T.

[Red_Wyrm]

Tappedout (which is a very biased list) has added a Tier (Tier 0- Overpowered). The only commanders on it are T&T.

I don't understand why there is bias. Isn't the entire point to have a liist that is objectionably all the commanders ranked by power level?

Do you play cEDH WWolfe?

[Soren841]

The point is to be objective. The people on TappedOut are not.

[WWolfe]

Soren can probably better answer that question than I can, but to me it seems to be a clique that controls the list.

I have a deck that I've recently built that would qualify as Tier 1.5 or 2 but I built it more for online play because I'll rarely get to play it at my LGS.

[Morganator 2.0]

Tier 0 is used to describe the best deck. When there is a Tier 0 deck in Modern or Standard, it means that the only way to beat it is to either play that deck, or a deck that specifically counters it.

While the people who run the TappedOut list are getting better, they do have strong biases and an aura of elitism. Most of the placements make sense, but other times they are super adamant on the positions of certain commanders, despite what the numbers show. They only recently brought Godo up a tier, and that deck has been around for a year now (since Dominaria). I still have reservations about the placements of Yisan, the Wanderer Bard and Taigam, Ojutai Master, but at this point it's minutae.