Post

1

Deck Comments / Re: I dont have friends - Comments

« il: Marzo 28, 2022, 07:41:43 pm »

how do you plan on getting lab man consistently

2

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Help - first deck - Kenrith EDH

« il: Gennaio 08, 2022, 10:03:38 pm »

I feel if your going to go all in on this you need more tax/protection for yourself, like Ghostly Prison / Propaganda and Crawlspace / Silent Arbiter / Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite

The problem with these cards is they are fairly expensive and might push him over budget, otherwise, they are great suggestions.

3

Deck Comments / Re: 4C Lotus Field - Comments

« il: Dicembre 28, 2021, 05:57:59 pm »

I am not very familiar with lotus field decks and I am wondering, how do they win?

4

Deck Comments / Re: U/B Runo - Comments

« il: Dicembre 28, 2021, 05:53:44 pm »

I would recommend using watery grave to make things like counterspell and vampire hexmage more consistently playable on turn two and three

5

Deck Comments / Re: Negative ETBs.. Don't Care Doe - Comments

« il: Dicembre 28, 2021, 05:16:29 pm »

voracious hatchling does’t have an etb so you may want to find an alternative

6

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Construction advice? Jared Carthalion, True Heir

« il: Dicembre 28, 2021, 02:44:42 am »

I don’t think Subira is worth it in this deck with how few small creatures you have in here, maybe mother of runes or giver of runes instead? They pull double duty by protecting your stuff, or making something unblockable by a color for a turn.

7

Commander Discussion / Re: Are 3-mana rocks still used?

« il: Dicembre 27, 2021, 05:52:58 pm »

How do the borderposts ramp you up? Let me see if I understand this.

• Turn 1 you play a basic (no other land will do).
• Tap it for one mana and return it to play the borderpost.
• Turn 2 you replay the basic. You're still at two mana on turn 2.

This is the same result if you instead choose to play two lands. Is there something I'm missing?

Nope, the only reason you would play them over a basic land is to play them as a 3 mana mana rock, basically any other rock is better than it, even the locket cycle is better.

8

About Deckstats / Re: UI updates and dark mode - now live!

« il: Dicembre 23, 2021, 06:04:28 pm »

I've also just noticed a tiny picture of your commander now appears instead of the decks colours when you're looking in your decklist folders. Not a fan of this page - you can't see the image very well because it's so small, the colour blocks were useful to see at a glance what colours I was playing a lot of across my decks.

I agree, if the picture was larger then it would be more useful but then it would take up more space as well, so i don’t know if it would actually improve anything.

now after all my criticism, I want to thank Nils for all the hard work and testing out new features, keep up the hard work.👍🏻

9

About Deckstats / Re: UI updates and dark mode - now live!

« il: Dicembre 23, 2021, 05:01:10 pm »

have you tried putting them in the maybeboard instead?

10

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: I've been trying to build Eloise, Nephalia Slueth. (still needs 2 cuts)

« il: Dicembre 23, 2021, 12:16:37 am »

Ummm, how would he add green to a UB deck? eloise is only two colors and green isn’t one of them, are you suggesting changing the commander completely?

11

Deck Reviews / Re: [Modern] Show a Sliver deck

« il: Dicembre 22, 2021, 10:52:23 pm »

why would people downvote this post? Seems unreasonable... so i decided to upvote do undo the damage but whoever did this, please don't downvote without cause, I see no reason for it here.

12

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: I've been trying to build Eloise, Nephalia Slueth. (still needs 2 cuts)

« il: Dicembre 22, 2021, 10:48:41 pm »

I think what my personal issue is, is that he already has 9 ramp spells, and the only one that locket might be better than is the crowded crypt, so suggesting locket didn't seem nessecary especially because he generally wants to be sacrificing tokens and creatures, of which dimir locket is neither, so the fact that it says "sacrifice" doesn't mean it fits in his deck.
I hope you understand where I am coming from now.

13

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: I've been trying to build Eloise, Nephalia Slueth. (still needs 2 cuts)

« il: Dicembre 22, 2021, 09:00:03 pm »

I would recommend adding more sac outlets, it seems you only have a total of 3 cards that sacrifice something other than lands.

14

Commander Deck Reviews / Re: I've been trying to build Eloise, Nephalia Slueth. (still needs 2 cuts)

« il: Dicembre 22, 2021, 06:19:13 pm »

That was just personal opinion. The rock artifact can be sacrificed really at turn 4 and give 2 cards. He plays from his deck a lot of card draw, surveil and investigate, he plays Time Sieve and Disciple of the Vault, he can sacrifice that artifact or tap it with Shimmer Dragon or with improvise of his cards. I don't know why you are so negative? Why can't I make a simple suggestion without getting downvoted? Really. Why such Cardinal animosity? The Dimir Signet really has to be pumped for mana and is good and gives double, but in my opinion Dimir Locket is just as good for his deck. He plays sacrifice, with drawing cards, improvise and surveil. What is wrong to state an opinion and make a suggestion? I am not arguing about rules. Why such Cardinal hatred and denial from you, Schau?
Regards and Merry Christmas, Bizzaro Soapy:
Chavo

why would you want to spend all your mana on turn three and four to draw two cards? I would much rather have a mind stone because it only costs 3 mana to play and sacrifice in one turn unlike locket that takes a total of 7 mana. Schau is not the only person who thinks that locket is worse than signet (shown by the downvotes on your post). I am not saying locket is a useless card, but generally I want my ramp to be ramp and my card draw to be card draw, if the ramp comes with card draw with no significant downsides, like mind stone, then I will include it,  but if it has the potential to be card draw but is also slower, it is only useful in very casual games.

Edit: Is it possible that the reason you are getting downvoted for your suggestion because your suggestion wasn’t that good in the first place? something to think about before saying that its because they don’t like you or they are doing it to intentionally hurt you.

Edit 2: where do you get the idea that Schau is in denial? what are they denying?

15

Deck Comments / Re: Competitive Krenko - Comments

« il: Dicembre 21, 2021, 08:05:03 pm »

Subira is honestly one of my favourite cards in krenko, I am glad to see that you included it, especially because not many other people use it. Is hobgoblin bandit lord worth it in this deck?