deckstats.net
You need to be logged in to do this.
The buttons above will open in a new window. Please return to this window after you have logged in. When you have logged in, click the Refresh Session button and then try again.

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Barfy

Pages: [1] 2 3
1
Deck Comments / Re: Vaevictis Primal Surge - Comments
« on: March 22, 2024, 06:02:14 pm »
Thanks for the card choice explanations in the (incomplete) primer. Your list has more unique cards to it than a lot of other lists I've seen, a lot of good considerations will come of your list going into what I end up with.

2
Deckstats Feedback / Re: Can't scroll through list
« on: February 05, 2024, 02:52:14 am »
I ran into this today as well. Imported a decklist from a moxfield list for the first time and thought something weird was up... took a look at some old decks I had made and I can't scroll down my list either. Was trying to disable chrome extensions and nothing worked.

3
Deck Comments / Re: Henzie's Kreature Krew - Comments
« on: April 30, 2023, 06:33:37 am »
Nice categories, creative companion choice. Thx for making a cool list

4
Deckstats Feedback / Re: Card Database
« on: April 22, 2023, 08:39:13 pm »
When I click on the spoilers for the new March of the Machines set, I get an Error: Set not Found message. I can't seem to find any of the new cards in the database either when deckbuilding - yet I can search for a new card in the deck searcher, for example Thalia and the Gitrog monster, and see that people have built decks for these cards. Something in my settings must be screwed up if other people are able to access these cards and I can't get them to load anywhere.

I would appreciate any help you guys can offer for fixing this on my end.

 I apologize if this is the wrong thread to ask this in, I will repost it wherever it's supposed to be.

5
If it's Lab Man you want, then Chord of Calling (which you have) for 5, copied with Kalamax, will get you Leveler and Thassa's Oracle, which will replace that wincon without ANY Draw power, plus it won't fall to Nars3t or Notion Thief (but instead to Opposition Agent). 

I am finally about ready to order / build this deck and I realized that this combo doesn't work. Copy 1 of the Chord of Calling pulls in the Leveler, which removes the library, thus copy 2 can't find thassa's oracle in that library.

6
Alright, I cut it down a bunch. Any thoughts in this decks' current form would be appreciated

7
Cool, thank you. Yeah, in that situation with Obliterate I would have had a lethal board state to leverage so that it never got cast as long as X could have been 2. (I was next in turn order)

I'll retool the deck tomorrow, thanks for your suggestions. I'll remove the redundancy of other creatures and cut down on fling effects and see where I'm at. I'm still curious about what other Forks I'm missing are out there, though.

I must seem like a real babe in the woods to you guys, but your input is greatly appreciated.


8
Hello guys, thank you for what you've shared with me so far.

Morganator, the thought was that Kalamax will be a lightning rod for removal and will eventually cost too much to cast. Having the magecraft creatures who get +1/+1 counters offer other (less efficient) routes for a big creature who can attack for lethal or be a target for Chandra's Ignition. Do you think the redundancy isn't necessary?

And the method to draw the entire deck was using a Greater Good style draw effect once a creature has been made really large.

jlutzxinc, thank you, I appreciate the wall of text because there's a lot to correct with this deck. Thank you for the #show_description lesson, I updated the original post. I'll take your advice chunk by chunk:

"you could even KEEP all three of your wincons, if you emphasized consistency over running every POSSIBLE card."
Do you think as a starting goal I should reduce the amount of cards in all of my categories to 9 or something? My main problem here is I don't know how to balance my copying effect ratio with the other pieces of the puzzle. The three main things are getting Kalamax tapped, be ready with a fork effect, and then have a way to win once I've copied those effects. If I cut all of my removal (of which I admit I went for weird chaos warp effects that seemed really fun instead of staples), and all of my protection, I'm still way over my card count. It seems like there isn't enough room to ever draw into the combo engine if I'm going by Normal Deckbuilding Advice™ of always having a chunk of ramp, removal, and protection.

I would appreciate if you bluntly told me which of my categories are unnecessary.

"Notably, Kalamax copying the first INSTANT could be leveraged (further than it already is) by FIRST casting a Sorcery-speed Tutor"
This never occurred to me because I don't like playing with tutors. This would certainly be the first step to ditching all the random crap in my deck and having it run consistently, but upon doing some scryfall searching I only see Solve the Equation as a sorcery speed tutor for what other instants/sorceries I want. Mystical Tutor does the same thing as an instant. Which ones am I missing?

"You're also missing a LOT of Fork effects;"
I am? There's only 12 fork effects at instant speed that come up while doing a scryfall search, (https://scryfall.com/search?q=id%3Atemur+t%3Ainstant+o%3A%22copy+target+instant%22) and 28 of them if I include all types of cards, which I didn't think would be too helpful as Kalamax only copies instants. What syntax am I missing to see what other fork effects you're talking about? This is a case of ignorance, I know old cards are worded differently but oftentimes I simply don't know how to find all instances of the effect I'm looking for.

"Ertai's Meddling will get rid of Dovin's Veto (I noticed you particularly hate that card).  If it's Lab Man you want, then Chord of Calling (which you have) for 5, copied with Kalamax, will get you Leveler and Thassa's Oracle, which will replace that wincon without ANY Draw power, plus it won't fall to Nars3t or Notion Thief (but instead to Opposition Agent)."
Awesome card suggestion, I didn't know that Ertai's Meddling existed, that's a great one to know about! I lost a game this past weekend to a friend casting Boros Charm and then Obliterate, I could have stopped it there too. I also hadn't known of using Leveler + Thassa's Oracle, that can really clean up having an alternate wincon without all the weird jankiness of my method to draw my deck, get lab man out somehow, then draw a final card. Thank you!

Maybe I need to put the words "Low Power Inconsistent Budget Jank Combo" into the deck title  :P

9
Hi there everyone, I've been making my first deck that uses infinite loops and have been having a blast. Building around Kalamax was really fun to discover new card interactions, but I fear that I've found too many cool strategies to try to jam into one deck! I am aiming to make a deck that makes an infinitely big creature, possibly fling it, and have a secondary lab man win condition sitting around in the deck.

Here is a link to the deck:

https://deckstats.net/decks/136478/2809875-kalamax-s-revenge#show_description

Do you guys think it would work at all to retain all three strategies, but just cut a ton of cards out of each pool of strategy?  I don't know how it could work without cutting all the removal and interaction... It's not fun to play solitare while assembling Exodia.

Thank you for any advice you could give to me!

10
Deck Comments / Re: IVY Gleeful Spellthief EDH - Comments
« on: August 26, 2022, 07:22:22 am »
Are the "combo" pieces there to let more Ivys exist and therefore go nuts with any subsequent cloning spells? I'm concerned that there's a lot of slots dedicated to copying / cloning without a whole lot of ways to keep the legend rule away. It's probably a very powerful way to build Ivy

11
God I wish this could be a community effort to keep this list updated

12
Deck Comments / Re: Beamtown Bullies - Comments
« on: July 28, 2022, 01:47:51 am »
Hey I'm glad to see after checkin' out what people have done with bully decks that the most liked one on deckstats is a copy of mine LOL keep on bullying brother!

14
Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Jon Irenicus, Shattered One
« on: June 05, 2022, 05:16:59 am »
Thank you for writing the deck explanation. I love you

15
Commander Deck Reviews / Re: Monoblack Mass Land Destruction
« on: December 15, 2021, 06:18:21 am »
This deck owns hard

Pages: [1] 2 3